Saturday, June 8, 2019

Daniel and the Ascending Son of Man



Sun Burst in the Clouds over the Mediterranean Sea

Sun Setting behind the Clouds over the Mediterranean Sea

Ascending Rainbow behind the Cloud 

The Book of Daniel contains stories, dreams, visions, interpretations, and prophecies centered on the Hebrew prophet named Daniel and his friends.  The work is considered apocalyptic literature that is highly symbolic.  The narrative of the book is set within Babylon during the 6th century B.C.E.   However, many of the events described in the visions refer to the state of affairs and incidents in the 2nd century B.C.E.  Thus, the book has been dated to the 6th century, 2nd century, or as a kind of hybrid from both centuries.  The story’s narrative takes place following the United Kingdom of Israel under King David, and the subsequent division and exiles of the tribes of Israel.  In this context, the narrative describes the rise of four kingdoms (chaps. 2 and 7).  Although the God of heaven has given the kingdom to the gentile rulers, things begin as a kind of golden age and then gradually decline until they are annihilated when struck by a stone cut from a mountain without human hands, and in those days God of heaven sets up a kingdom that will stand forever (chap. 2).  Daniel later records a dream of visions in his head that describe four beasts coming out of the sea (chap. 7).  He finally sees in his visions,

I saw one like a Son of Man (כְּבַ֥ר אֱנָ֖שׁ)[1]

coming with the clouds of heaven.

And he came to the Ancient One

and was presented (קרב) before him.

To him was given dominion

and glory and kingship,

that all peoples, nations, and languages

should serve him. [2]

The meaning and interpretation of the “Son of Man” is problematic.  It is based on the Hebrew phrase כְּבַ֥ר אֱנָ֖שׁ, “one like a ‘Son of Man’” that is sometimes simply translated as one like a “human” or “human being.”[3]  The identity of the “Son of Man” has been discussed since ancient times.  There have been three basic interpretations: 1) an early Jewish interpretation saw the “Son of Man” as an individual figure who is the anointed or chosen one—that is, the Messiah; an early Christian interpretation saw this as a reference to Christ and to his second coming; 2) a collective symbol that represents the entire Jewish people; and 3) an individual that represents not the Messiah, but rather a heavenly angelic being.[4]

Perhaps a helpful way to understand the “Son of Man” in relation to the four beasts in Daniel is to compare them with the creation account in Genesis where God is gradually creating space, order, vegetation, sea monsters, living creatures, and finally אָדָם, man (humankind) in his own image; God then rested on the seventh day after “the heavens and the earth were finished,” with all their hosts, וְכָל־צְבָאָֽם; and God blessed it and hallowed it (Gen 2:1).[5] 

In Daniel, the four beasts are described as four kings that shall arise out of the earth (Dan 7:17).  The first beast was like a lion, the second a bear, third like a leopard, and the fourth was terrifying and frightful (vv. 4-8).  The fourth beast is interpreted as a fourth kingdom that will arise from the earth, different from all other kingdoms, and shall devour all the earth (v. 23).  These kingdoms have been interpreted at least in two ways.  The first view understands the kingdoms as the empires of Babylon, then the Medo-Persian, then the Greco-Seleucid, and finally the Roman Empire.[6]  The second view argues that the kingdoms are the empires of Babylon, the Medes, the Persians, and finally the Greeks.[7]

Regardless of which view one favors, both agree that the first beast refers to Babylon.  Thus, the following should accommodate both interpretations.  The religious backgrounds of Daniel are clearly behind the narrative.  King Nebuchadnezzar of Babylon brings an end to the kingdom of Judah and brings back some of the vessels from the temple of Jerusalem (Dan 1:1-2).  The king is told that the God of heaven has given him the kingdom (2:36-38), after which the king worships Daniel and confesses the God of Daniel (2:46-47).  However, eventually Nebuchadnezzar will set up a golden image of himself and then order all “peoples, nations, and languages” to worship his image (3:1-7).  All comply except Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, whom the king punishes by casting them into a furnace of blazing fire (vv. 8-23).  Fortunately, they are vindicated with the presence of a mysterious figure who was likened to “a son of [the] gods,” לְבַר־אֱלָהִֽין (vv. 24-30; esp. v. 25).  Unfortunately for Nebuchadnezzar, he is humbled for his error of judgment; he is driven away from society and wanders about like an animal until he acknowledges the sovereignty of the Most High (4:1-33).  After this is over, Nebuchadnezzar lifts his eyes to heaven and his knowledge returns to him, and he blesses and praises the King of heaven (vv. 34-37). 

Things will quickly change with King Belshazzar who celebrated a great feast in which he took vessels of gold and silver, which had been taken from the Jerusalem temple by Nebuchadnezzar; Belshazzar uses them to drink wine and praise the gods of gold, silver, bronze, timber, and stone (5:1-4).  However, the writing was on the wall.  Like Nebuchadnezzar, he is rebuked and eventually the kingdom will be taken from him (vv. 5-30).  

During the rule of King Darius, the king’s administrators and satraps attempt and succeed in having Daniel accused, arrested and then thrown into a lion’s den because three times a day Daniel would face Jerusalem to pray, praise, and seek mercy before God (6:1-11).  Although he is thrown into the lion’s den (vv. 16-18), Daniel is rescued through an angel, after which King Darius is relieved with gladness, has Daniel removed and his accusers thrown into the lion’s den, and then encourages all peoples and nations of every language to honor the God of Daniel (vv. 19-28).

These events help set the stage for what follows in chapter 7 where Daniel receives visions of the four beasts, the Ancient of Days, judgment, the arrogant horn, the death of the fourth beast, and the Son of Man.[8]  The four beasts represent four kings (or kingdoms) that will arise from the earth in a kind of sequence as the dominant world power one after another (v. 17), after which the holy ones will receive the kingdom forever (v. 18).  There is a slight variation later in the chapter that states, “the greatness of the kingdoms under the whole heaven shall be given to the people of the holy ones of the Most High” (v. 27).

How does the Son of Man fit into the sequence of kingdoms?  The answer appears earlier in the same chapter in verses 13-14 where the vision describes the Son of Man who ascended to the Ancient of Days and was presented before him, and to him was given the kingship so that all peoples, nations, tongues, and tribes might serve him.  Although the four prior kingdoms arise from the earth, the one like the Son of Man ascends to the Ancient of Days. 

It should be noted that the saying, the “Son of Man was presented (קרב) before the Ancient of Days” (Dan 7:13), has another interpretation.  The Hebrew word קרב translated as “presented,” can also mean to offer sacrifice.[9]  Margaret Baker goes as far to say that it is “the technical term for making a temple offering, and so the Man was ‘offered’ to the Ancient of Days.”[10]  Questions arise such as who did the offering?  Did the Son of Man offer himself? Was it someone else who made the offering?  This becomes more complicated when we realize that the interpretation of the Son of Man reveals that he also represents the people of God (vv. 18, 27).  Is it the people of God who are making the offering?  Or is it the Son of Man who is offering up the people of God? 

Also, is it possible that the ascension of the Son of Man also represents the lifting up of the people?  It may well be the case.  We saw above that before Elijah was taken into heaven, he offered up an acceptable sacrifice that represented the twelve tribes of Israel.  We also saw above that when David ascended up to Mount Zion with the Ark of the Covenant, he was accompanied by all of Israel. 

There are several passages in the New Testament that echo this parallel between the Son of Man and the people.  One of the most notable examples is found in John’s Gospel where Jesus is identified with the Son of Man (chap. 12).  In particular, Jesus says, “when I am lifted up from the earth…I will draw all people to myself” (Jn 12:32).[11]  According to First Peter, Christ suffered for sins once and for all in order to bring the people to God (1 Pet 3:18).  Through the mercy of God, the people have been raised up with Christ and seated with him in the heavens (Eph 2:4-6).  It is the mystery of God’s will to gather up all things in him, both things in heaven and things on earth (1:10).  Finally, those who share in the “flesh” and “blood” of the Son of Man (Jn 6:53-56), also share in the ascending Son of Man (vv. 62-63).  In chapter 17, Jesus prays that those who believe in him might all be one as the Father and Son are one (v. 21), and that they might be with him (v. 24). 

This last section was rather long, but its summary will be brief.  The book of Daniel describes the rise of four kingdoms (chaps. 2 and 7).  Daniel understands that the God of heaven has given the kingdom to the gentile rulers.  Although things begin as a kind of golden age, they gradually decline until they are annihilated when struck by a stone cut from a mountain without human hands; in those days the God of heaven sets up a kingdom that will stand forever (chap. 2).  Daniel later records a dream of visions in his head that describe four beasts coming out of the sea (chap. 7).  These beasts represent the four kingdoms in chapter 2.  The fourth beast, representing the fourth kingdom, represents all that is hostile toward God, God’s people, and God’s covenant.  In the end, the beast is destroyed.  Daniel also sees one like a Son of Man ascending over death and destruction up to the Ancient of Days.  This ascension dimension is not a mere burnt offering; rather it is human, personal, and communal.  All of the people of God will be a living sacrifice presented and acceptable to God.



[1] I capitalized Son of Man for emphasis. LFL.
[2] The Holy Bible: New Revised Standard Version (Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 1989), Da 7:13–14.  Ed. LFL.
[3] The NRSV has “human being,” the NASB “Son of Man,” the ESV and NIV have “son of man.” LFL.
[4] John Joseph Collins and Adela Yarbro Collins, Daniel: A Commentary on the Book of Daniel (ed. Frank Moore Cross; Hermeneia—a Critical and Historical Commentary on the Bible; Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1993), 306-310.
[5] See Neh 9:6; Ps 33:6; Isa 45:12; 40:26; 34:2.
[6] For example, John Phillips, Exploring the Book of Daniel (Grand Rapids: Kregel, 2004), 116. *
[7] See NJBC, 411; Samuel Rolles Driver, The Book of Daniel: with Introduction and Notes (London: C. J. Clay and Sons, 1900), 94-95.*  For arguments in favor of this view, see Robert J. M. Gurney, “The Four Kingdoms of Daniel 2 and 7,” Themelios: Volume 2, No. 2, 1977 (1977): 39.*
[8] The text uses the term חזה (vision) eight times, once as a noun (7:1), and seven times as a peal participle (vv. 2, 4, 6, 7, 9, 11 (2x), 13).

[9] BDB 1111.2. 
[10] Margaret Barker, Temple Mysticism: An Introduction (London: SPCK, 2011), 150.
[11] Some ancient versions have “all things.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

Indigenous Leaders in Solidarity with Historical Jewish Connection to the Land of Israel

This news article took me by surprise.   A group of indigenous leaders gathered in Jerusalem from around the world to support the historical...